top of page

Why Did Martin O’Neill Drop Haissem Hassan? Analysing Celtic’s Wing Dilemma

6 minutes ago
3 min read
After a bright second-half cameo against Besiktas, Haissem Hassan was left out of the matchday squad for the Kilmarnock victory prior to the international break. Having suffered an unspecified injury on international duty in September, most of the Celtic fanbase presumed that the Egyptian had picked up another knock.

Two hours later, and after a less-than-inspiring 1-0 victory, Martin O’Neill revealed that his omission was in fact planned, stating:


“How is [Hassan]? We’re trying to do, as much as possible, we’re trying to do a bit of manoeuvring at this minute. I just think it’ll be great for places. If there’s proper competition for places, it can only make us better.”


Therefore, both James Forrest and Sebastian Tounekti were named ahead of the 24-year-old.


My first question would be: Why?


My second would be: Can you manufacture competition for places? Surely such a situation arises as a by-product of squad depth?


Take Ange Postecoglou’s Celtic side. At the beginning of the 2022/23 season, Liel Abada, Kyogo, Georgios Giakoumakis, Jota, Daizen Maeda, James Forrest and Sead Haksabanovic were all on the books. With so much quality, competition for places arrived naturally.


“Big Ange” didn’t feel the need to mix up the pecking order to create a sense of competition. It was inherently present due to the depth available.



Switching Hassan for Tounekti, who, in my opinion, is a poorer-quality player, doesn’t magically create competition. It just creates frustration, confusion and rumours about potential reasons for exclusion.


Admittedly, since joining in the summer from Real Oviedo for an initial fee of £6 million, Hassan’s defensive capabilities, or lack thereof, have been continuously questioned. He has often left Colby Donovan with 2-v-1 situations and has consistently lacked defensive awareness.


Yet, you can hardly argue that this has justified his exclusion in favour of Tounekti. After all, per ninety minutes, their defensive numbers are very similar. Hassan regains the ball in the opposition’s final third 0.83 times. In comparison, Tounekti’s ratio is 0.71.


Moreover, if failing to mark and follow players were a criterion for exclusion, MON would be struggling to name a midfield each matchday. He would also need to seriously consider his captain’s role.


In attack, Hassan’s current drought of [71 games without a goal] is simply inexcusable.


Yet, at the same time, you don’t need to be a goalscorer to be effective. For a team that struggles to play through the opposition due to a highly dysfunctional midfield, players such as Hassan, who can progress the Hoops up the park, are priceless.


It’s why the likes of Colby Donovan, Kieran Tierney, Yang Hyun-jun, Camilo Duran, Callum Osmand and, of course, Alistair Johnston (when he returns) are so important for this current Celtic side.


It’s why Daizen Maeda was so effective last season.


Moreover, it’s not all terrible news for Hassan regarding his attacking output. He ranks third for Celtic in key passes (passes leading to shots) and has the second-highest expected assist rate in the league, behind Tierney.


Truthfully, Hassan can cross. He often floats dangerous balls to the back post; it’s just that most of Celtic’s aerial ability comes from the backline. Put a player like Giorgos Giakoumakis or Adam Idah in those positions and the Egyptian would have many more assists to his name.


A simple way of looking at things is whether Celtic are a better team when he plays. So far, I would argue that has been the case. He started in the 7-1 victory over Hearts; came on for the second half against Benfica, where the Hoops were dangerous, and featured in the second-half late show against Besiktas.


So, to completely ostracise him from proceedings seems bizarre, though it has not been uncommon during MON’s second tenure.


After running the midfield at Ibrox in a second-half comeback, Reo Hatate was barely seen for the rest of last season. Similarly, Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain excelled in the number six role against Falkirk and Aberdeen but has only made one start since.


So where should Hassan’s place in the squad be?


When everyone is fully fit and firing, Yang and Jota are Celtic’s best options out wide. So, in an ideal world, you can then bring the pace and directness of Hassan and Osmand off the bench.


Therefore, when Celtic return to action against St Mirren this afternoon, Hassan should be back in the squad.



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page